ballet, don quixote, ballerina, performance, performer, dancer, dancing, venezuela, ballet, ballet, ballet, ballerina, ballerina, ballerina, ballerina, ballerina, dancer, venezuela

Ballet Traditions and Contemporary Demands

Cultural Sensitivity and Evolution

The world of ballet, rich in history and tradition, faces an ongoing dialogue between its classical heritage and the evolving demands of contemporary society, particularly concerning cultural sensitivity, diversity, and representation.

Addressing Problematic Representations in Classical Ballets

Many historical ballets contain national and racial stereotypes that are problematic from a modern perspective. A prominent example is Marius Petipa’s The Nutcracker, where orientalism is evident in the Land of Sweets scene, featuring characters representing various cultures, such as Chinese tea and Arabian coffee. These portrayals were often built on stereotypical and Western imaginations, with white dancers traditionally performing these roles, sometimes with their skin painted darker (blackface) and their movement styles adapted to assumed “oriental” mannerisms based entirely on stereotypes.

It is crucial to consider the historical context: during Petipa’s era, dancers of Arab or Chinese descent were not typically part of his company. Therefore, in that specific historical context, these practices may not have been perceived as racist in the same way they are today. However, the circumstances of the time and the choreography itself have led to these older ballets being viewed as culturally insensitive or even racist from a contemporary standpoint. Despite these problematic elements, traditional ballets hold significant cultural value and are meaningful, making their preservation for future generations important.   

To prevent these valuable works from becoming “dead documents,” it is essential to preserve traditional ballet while simultaneously reinterpreting them and bringing forth their socio-cultural context. This approach allows for a deeper understanding of why certain practices were acceptable in their time and how they can be reinterpreted to align with modern values.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Contemporary Ballet

The ideals of diversity, equity, and inclusion are increasingly central to the ballet world today. Diversity in ballet refers to the representation of individuals from various backgrounds, including different races, ethnicities, genders, sexual orientations, body types, and socio-economic statuses, encompassing all the different characteristics that make one individual or group different from another. Equity, in this context, is the process of modifying practices that have intentionally or unintentionally disadvantaged a particular group, aiming for all people to have an equal opportunity to succeed. It is important to acknowledge that the definition and implementation of equality can vary across different cultures globally.   

Ballet companies are actively addressing the need for reform by creating a dialogue between traditional practices and contemporary demands. For instance, the Finnish National Opera and Ballet has introduced representation guidelines (since spring 2023) to better recognize and address challenges related to ethnic minorities (e.g., racialization, exoticism, orientalism), body image, and the portrayal of violence and intimate scenes in their productions. This proactive approach helps ensure that performances reflect contemporary values and resonate with diverse audiences. With personnel from 34 nationalities, modern ballet companies, particularly those with diverse dancers, are uniquely positioned to reinterpret these ballets, bringing new perspectives and enhancing their representation. Similarly, organizations like the Atlanta Ballet and the School of American Ballet have implemented diversity and inclusion initiatives, focusing on organizational culture, inclusive training programs, and reflecting community demographics on stage.

This reinterpretation and socio-cultural contextualization are crucial for traditional ballets to maintain their valuable cultural mark and avoid becoming mere historical artifacts. Contemporary ballet, which blends classical technique with modern movements and explores abstract concepts, offers a powerful avenue for this evolution. It emphasizes expressive, fluid motions, uses unconventional music, and often features minimalist costumes, pushing the boundaries of the art form while maintaining its classical roots.

Pioneering Choreographers and the Evolution of Ballet

Modern choreographers have played a pivotal role in challenging traditional ballet concepts and creating works that reflect contemporary values and questions, thereby enriching the art form’s depth and versatility.

George Balanchine (1904–1983), often hailed as the father of modern classical ballet, revolutionized the art form by stripping it of its dependence on narrative and elaborate spectacle, presenting it in a pure, classical form. He synthesized classical ballet with other styles, subtly incorporating elements of jazz and American folk dances like hoedowns. Balanchine’s “plotless” ballets, often referred to as his “Black and White” works due to their simple costumes, focused attention entirely on the dancers’ movement and musicality, demonstrating that ballet could be as inventive and experimental as other art forms. He redefined ballet from within, using its tradition as a springboard for experimentation.

William Forsythe (b. 1949) is a trailblazer known for pushing the boundaries of ballet, mesmerizing audiences with bold artistic experimentation. His unique style combines classical technique with modern athleticism, expanding ballet’s fundamental structures to create something uniquely contemporary while still celebrating classical vocabulary. Forsythe’s work is characterized by complex, intricate movement patterns, technical difficulty, and an innovative use of improvisation and collaboration, often incorporating elements of theater, music, visual art, and new technologies like video and digital projections.

Michel Fokine (1880–1942) transformed traditional ballet with dynamic movements and expressive storytelling, bringing emotional depth and narrative to the stage. As a key choreographer for Sergei Diaghilev’s Ballets Russes, he created landmark works like The Firebird and Petrouchka, emphasizing the importance of careful research into cultural traditions underlying a ballet’s setting. Fokine aimed to liberate ballet from its academic straitjacket, jettisoning the formulaic conventions of his predecessor, Marius Petipa, and revitalizing the classical vocabulary by freeing dancers’ arms and spines from rigid adherence to traditional poses. His “tone poems” used new musical forms and subordinated showy technique to dramatic expression.

Alexander Gorsky (1871–1924) was an influential Russian choreographer known for restaging Petipa’s classical ballets with a focus on greater naturalism, realism, and characterization. He valued acting skills over bravura technique and often used artists outside the dance world for sets and costumes. Gorsky notably reshaped the role of the corps de ballet, transforming them from a static background into an important, bustling, and culturally relevant part of the drama, breaking the symmetry typical of Petipa’s works. He was inspired by Isadora Duncan’s belief that dance should be a natural expression of the soul and Konstantin Stanislavski’s acting system.

In Finland, Jorma Uotinen (b. 1950) stands as a major figure in performing arts, known for his bold and innovative choreographies that combine classical ballet technique with modern dance and expressive styles. Uotinen’s extensive career includes almost 80 creations, and he has served as artistic director for the Helsinki City Theatre Dance Company and the Finnish National Ballet. His work, sometimes described as “open dance,” has involved collaborations with visual arts, and his intensively visual choreographies often draw inspiration from artists like Jérôme Bosch and René Magritte. Uotinen’s approach highlights the fusion of classical lightness with the weight and groundedness of contemporary dance, reflecting the human body’s inherent weight.

Conclusion

Furthermore, the ongoing evolution of ballet demonstrates its capacity for self-reflection and adaptation. By critically examining historical works, addressing cultural insensitivities, and embracing diversity and inclusion, the art form ensures its continued relevance. The pioneering work of choreographers like Balanchine, Forsythe, Fokine, Gorsky, and Uotinen exemplifies how ballet can break traditions, reflect contemporary values, and maintain its profound cultural significance while constantly pushing artistic boundaries. This dialogue between tradition and innovation is vital for ballet to remain a living, evolving art form that resonates with audiences worldwide.

Sources

Atlanta Ballet. Diversity and Inclusion initiatives. https://www.atlantaballet.com/about/diversity-and-inclusion-initiatives  

Finnish national Ooppera and Ballet. Guidelines for reviewing representation. https://oopperabaletti.fi/en/sustainability/